Defra committee suggests changes to farm policy

The House of Commons Defra Committee has some sensible and politically feasible suggestions in relation to recent Government farming policy.  Full report is accessible here: https://committees.parliament.uk/work/8722/the-future-of-farming/publications/

'Closing the Sustainable Farming Incentive 2024 (SFI24) without notice affected confidence in the Environmental Land Management Schemes (ELMS). This must be repaired to secure their future success. An alternative funding mechanism should be put in place to fill the gap in funding for those who missed out on the SFI24, and the Government should set out details of the next iteration of SFI as a priority. 

 We support the Government’s objective of reforming agricultural property relief (APR) and business property relief (BPR) to close the loophole that has encouraged wealthy investors to buy agricultural land to avoid inheritance tax. We are concerned, however, that no consultation, impact assessment or affordability assessment was conducted before the announcement of the reforms. 

The lack of proper evaluation of the impact of these changes 1 means that the scale and nature of its impact on family farms, land values, tenant farmers, food security and farmers in the devolved administrations is disputed and unclear. This comes with a considerable risk of negative unintended consequences. 

 Alternatives to the Government’s approach have been proposed, which may achieve the same policy outcomes while protecting vulnerable farmers. We are not in a position to assess the merits of each alternative but there is sufficient time for the Government to do so. Stakeholder concerns about the Budget’s taxation proposals have made it difficult for Government to articulate and deliver its wider vision. 

A pause in the implementation of the reforms would allow for better tax policy to be developed and the Government to convey a positive long-term vision. The Government should delay announcing its final APR and BPR reforms until October 2026, to come into effect in April 2027. This would also provide farmers with more time to seek appropriate professional advice.'

Farmers are unfortunately notoriously poor at succession planning and they need more time to adjust.